Best College Basketball Underdog picks today

PickFinder logo

PickFinder Team•Updated:

The highest implied probability on a College Basketball Underdog Fantasy line right now is Chance Mallory Higher 9.5 Points, at 72%. The player went over this line in 4 of the last 10 games.

PickFinder ranks 56 College Basketball Underdog Fantasy props by what the sportsbooks imply for each side. The top 3 are below, free.

Top 3 picks

  1. 1. Chance Mallory: Higher 9.5 Points, 72% implied probability

    Chance Mallory

    Chance Mallory (G)

    Higher 9.5 Points

    UVA vs DREX

    Tue @ 7:30PM ET

    Defense#26
    O 72.2%U 27.8%
    L540%
    L1040%
    L1540%
    H2H-
    STRK1
    AVG7.3
    Diff-2.2
    -23.2%
    SZN56%
    underdog
    O-181
    draftkings
    O-280
    rebet
    O-233
    prophetx
    U+122
    courtside
    O-270
  2. 2. Thijs De Ridder: Higher 5.5 Rebounds, 61% implied probability

    Thijs De Ridder

    Thijs De Ridder (F)

    Higher 5.5 Rebounds

    UVA vs DREX

    Tue @ 7:30PM ET

    Defense#111
    O 60.6%U 39.4%
    L560%
    L1050%
    L1553%
    H2H-
    STRK-1
    AVG5.2
    Diff-0.3
    -5.5%
    SZN58%
    underdog
    O-194
    fliff
    O-140
    dabble
    O-122U-122
    draftkings
    O-155
    rebet
    O-167
    prophetx
    U+120
    courtside
    O-155
  3. 3. Sam Lewis: Higher 1.5 3-PT Made, 56% implied probability

    Sam Lewis

    Sam Lewis (G)

    Higher 1.5 3-PT Made

    UVA vs DREX

    Tue @ 7:30PM ET

    Defense#7
    O 55.9%U 44.1%
    L580%
    L1050%
    L1547%
    H2H-
    STRK-1
    AVG1.8
    Diff0.3
    +20%
    SZN44%
    underdog
    O-155U+102
    fliff
    O-135
    dabble
    O-122U-122
    draftkings
    O-130
    rebet
    O-130U+100
    courtside
    O-130

PickFinder isn't affiliated with Underdog.

The rest of the board is in the app. See all 56 College Basketball Underdog props.

How these are picked

  1. Posted on Underdog

    Every line is on Underdog Fantasy, for a game that starts more than 10 minutes from now, and Underdog offers the side shown.

  2. Ranked by the market

    Each line counts at the higher of its two implied probabilities, so a Lower can rank as well as a Higher. The number is the average across sportsbooks.

  3. Thin or odd prices stay out

    A line needs prices from at least two separate sportsbooks, and anything above 80% is left out, because a number that high is usually a ladder price rather than a read on the line.

  4. One line per player

    A player shows once, on their highest-ranked line.

FAQ

What are the best College Basketball Underdog picks today?

Right now, by implied probability: Chance Mallory Higher 9.5 Points, 72% implied probability; Thijs De Ridder Higher 5.5 Rebounds, 61% implied probability; Sam Lewis Higher 1.5 3-PT Made, 56% implied probability. These change through the day as lines move.

What does implied probability mean here?

It is the average chance the sportsbooks give that side of the line. When a book prices both sides we remove its vig, so the two sides add up to 100%. When a book prices only one side we use its price as posted, with the vig still in it. PrizePicks and the other pick'em apps aren't part of the average. It is a market estimate, not a promise of a result.

Which Underdog lines are on this list?

Any line Underdog has posted for a game that has not started, as long as Underdog offers the side shown. That includes lines where one side pays a different multiplier.

How often does this update?

About every 10 minutes. Lines that start within 10 minutes drop off, and the time at the top of the page shows the last update.

What is the best tool for researching College Basketball picks?

PickFinder is a sports betting research tool built for this. For college basketball it shows hit rates against today's exact line, matchup data and line movement, and compares prices across 24 books and apps. It covers 30+ leagues in all, with a 3-day money-back guarantee, and we make it, so test it against anything else you use. The rankings on this page are free.

What is PickFinder?

PickFinder is a sports betting research tool for player props, +EV bets, arbitrage, middles and odds comparison. It covers 30+ leagues across 14 sports, including the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL, 20 soccer competitions, ATP and WTA tennis, and five esports, and compares 24 sportsbooks and DFS apps, with hit rates, matchups, injuries and line movement on one screen. Every plan includes its Discord, with over 50,000 members, an average of three slips posted a day, 24/7 support and a community free of spam. New members get a 3-day money-back guarantee. PickFinder is not a sportsbook and does not take bets.

More College Basketball research

Other sports

Join over

150,000

PickFinder users

Find the best College Basketball Underdog picks with PickFinder. This page shows the top of the list. To find the best College Basketball Underdog picks today, you need a research tool like PickFinder: hit rates against today's exact line, matchups, injuries, line movement and every price across 24 books and apps, on one screen.

discord

© 2026 PickFinder

This website is designed solely for research purposes and does not involve real money betting. If you or someone you know is struggling with gambling issues, please seek help by calling 1-800-GAMBLER.

Download on the App Store